D/ST scoring comparison

Is It Whiskey · 2026 Week 1 · September 9–14

Snapshot: September 15, 2026, 12:47 p.m. ET · All 16 games completed · Subject to stat corrections

Points from 10 starting D/STs

70.062.5

−7.5 points (−10.7%) across the league

D/ST share of league scoring

5.53%4.96%

−0.56 percentage points

Matchup winners changed

0 of 5

4 teams scored more · 5 less · 1 unchanged

Impact on fantasy teams

Same starters and non-D/ST scoring in both calculations. Change = custom minus default.

Sleeper defaultCustom
Fantasy teamD/ST pointsTotal team pointsChange in team score
JohnBAL D/ST7.010.5134.78138.28
+3.5
Gibbs and the GoldrushPHI D/ST4.07.0143.14146.14
+3.0
Dak to the FutureDEN D/ST3.04.5160.46161.96
+1.5
Bucky Barnes BrigadeLAC D/ST1.01.5120.72121.22
+0.5
My Guitar Jeanty WeepsLAR D/ST2.02.0127.52127.52
0.0
Brock Hard on OnlyFanninsHOU D/ST−1.0−1.5133.16132.66
−0.5
OnlyInactivesNE D/ST6.04.094.1892.18
−2.0
He was a Skattebo-iPIT D/ST20.017.0140.34137.34
−3.0
lovethedrakeSEA D/ST13.09.5123.16119.66
−3.5
Ceedees Nuts HurtsJAX D/ST15.08.089.1682.16
−7.0

Jacksonville produced the largest change among starting defenses: −7.0 points for Ceedees Nuts Hurts. Baltimore produced the largest increase: +3.5 for John.

D/ST’s share of total scoring

Sleeper defaultCustom

The two largest scoring differences

Ranked by absolute difference across all 32 defenses, including defenses that were not started.

Cincinnati Bengals

vs. TB · Not rostered in the league

−12.5 pts
Sleeper default22.0
Custom9.5
Scoring componentDefaultCustomChange
Sacks4 sacks4.00.0−4.0
Forced fumbles4 forced fumbles4.00.0−4.0
Three non-TD recoveriesCustom: TB 33 (+2.5), CIN 20 (+1.5), TB 44 (+2.5)6.06.5+0.5
Fumble-return TD + recoveryDefault: +6 TD and +2 recovery. Custom: +6 TD only.8.06.0−2.0
Scoring allowedDefault: 21 points allowed. Custom: 2 TDs (−2), 2 FGs (−1).0.0−3.0−3.0
Total22.09.5−12.5

Default scoring gives 16 points for sacks, forced fumbles and recoveries, plus 6 for the touchdown. Custom scoring gives 6.5 for three non-TD possessions and 6 for the touchdown, then deducts 3 for scoring allowed.

The custom total includes a verified +6 fumble-return TD omitted by the live calculation. See the reconciliation notes below.

ESPN play-by-play ↗

Dallas Cowboys

vs. NYG · Not rostered in the league

−9.0 pts
Sleeper default7.0
Custom−2.0
Scoring componentDefaultCustomChange
Sacks2 sacks2.00.0−2.0
Forced fumbles4 forced fumbles4.00.0−4.0
Fumble recoveryCustom: next possession at DAL 16 (+1)2.01.0−1.0
Punt possessionCustom: next possession at DAL 15 (+1)0.01.0+1.0
Scoring allowedDefault: 28 points allowed. Custom: 4 TDs (−4).−1.0−4.0−3.0
Total7.0−2.0−9.0

Default scoring gives 8 points for sacks, forced fumbles and the recovery, then deducts 1 for points allowed. Custom scoring gives 2 for the two resulting possessions, then deducts 4 for touchdowns allowed.

ESPN play-by-play ↗

All 32 NFL defenses

These summaries include unstarted defenses; they do not represent league points earned.

Sleeper defaultCustom
Average D/ST score7.005.81
Median D/ST score6.05.5
Negative D/ST scores14
Higher / lower / unchanged14 / 16 / 2
View all 32 scores
32 defenses
Defense−40102024DefaultCustomChange
CINCincinnati Bengalsvs. TB · Not rostered22.09.5−12.5
DALDallas Cowboysvs. NYG · Not rostered7.0−2.0−9.0
JAXJacksonville Jaguarsvs. CLE · Started15.08.0−7.0
TBTampa Bay Buccaneersvs. CIN · Not rostered9.03.5−5.5
ATLAtlanta Falconsvs. PIT · Not rostered6.011.0+5.0
LVLas Vegas Raidersvs. MIA · Not rostered15.010.0−5.0
BALBaltimore Ravensvs. IND · Started7.010.5+3.5
CLECleveland Brownsvs. JAX · Not rostered1.0−2.5−3.5
SEASeattle Seahawksvs. NE · Started13.09.5−3.5
BUFBuffalo Billsvs. HOU · Not rostered8.05.0−3.0
CARCarolina Panthersvs. CHI · Not rostered1.0−2.0−3.0
NONew Orleans Saintsvs. DET · Not rostered3.06.0+3.0
PHIPhiladelphia Eaglesvs. WSH · Started4.07.0+3.0
PITPittsburgh Steelersvs. ATL · Started20.017.0−3.0
NYGNew York Giantsvs. DAL · Not rostered3.00.5−2.5
NENew England Patriotsvs. SEA · Started6.04.0−2.0
NYJNew York Jetsvs. TEN · Not rostered9.011.0+2.0
WSHWashington Commandersvs. PHI · Not rostered3.05.0+2.0
ARIArizona Cardinalsvs. LAC · Not rostered11.012.5+1.5
DENDenver Broncosvs. KC · Started3.04.5+1.5
DETDetroit Lionsvs. NO · Not rostered11.09.5−1.5
SFSan Francisco 49ersvs. LAR · Not rostered10.08.5−1.5
TENTennessee Titansvs. NYJ · Not rostered0.01.5+1.5
CHIChicago Bearsvs. CAR · Not rostered6.07.0+1.0
MINMinnesota Vikingsvs. GB · Not rostered10.09.0−1.0
GBGreen Bay Packersvs. MIN · Not rostered1.01.5+0.5
HOUHouston Texansvs. BUF · Started−1.0−1.5−0.5
INDIndianapolis Coltsvs. BAL · Not rostered1.01.5+0.5
KCKansas City Chiefsvs. DEN · Not rostered13.013.5+0.5
LACLos Angeles Chargersvs. ARI · Started1.01.5+0.5
LARLos Angeles Ramsvs. SF · Started2.02.00.0
MIAMiami Dolphinsvs. LV · Not rostered4.04.00.0

† CIN and CHI include play-by-play reconciliations described below. No starting defense required a reconciliation.

Matchup margins

Each row lists the winner under both systems. Values are winning margins in points.

Winning team / opponentDefault marginCustom marginMargin change
Johnvs. My Guitar Jeanty Weeps7.2610.76+3.50
Dak to the Futurevs. Gibbs and the Goldrush17.3215.82−1.50
Brock Hard on OnlyFanninsvs. Bucky Barnes Brigade12.4411.44−1.00
lovethedrakevs. OnlyInactives28.9827.48−1.50
He was a Skattebo-ivs. Ceedees Nuts Hurts51.1855.18+4.00
Scoring rules, calculations and sources

Calculation

Week 1’s actual starting lineups are held fixed. Non-D/ST scores use Sleeper’s individual starter points under this league’s scoring settings. Each team total is rebuilt as the sum of those points plus exactly one D/ST score. Sleeper’s team-level totals and commissioner overrides are not added again.

“Default” means Sleeper’s fixed NFL D/ST preset, verified September 9, 2026, applied to Sleeper’s Week 1 statistics. It does not use this league’s zeroed D/ST rates or Sleeper’s precomputed standard score. “Custom” applies the league’s possession-based rules to ESPN drive and play data, with the two documented report adjustments below.

League D/ST share = sum of starting D/ST points ÷ sum of total team points. This is a weighted league percentage, not an average of the ten team percentages. Only D/ST scoring changes. No lineup optimization or hypothetical roster moves are assumed. Displayed values are rounded after calculations.

Scoring rules used

Sleeper default

Sack +1; interception +2; fumble recovery +2; forced fumble +1; safety +2; blocked kick +2; defensive TD +6; special-teams TD +6; special-teams forced fumble +1; special-teams fumble recovery +1. Distinct stat categories add together.

Points allowed: 0 → +10; 1–6 → +7; 7–13 → +4; 14–20 → +1; 21–27 → 0; 28–34 → −1; 35+ → −4. Uses Sleeper’s D/ST points-allowed statistic, not the opponent’s scoreboard total.

Custom

Resulting possession: inside own 20 → +1; own 20 through midfield → +1.5; opponent 49–20 → +2.5; inside opponent 20 → +3.5. Eligible events include punts, interceptions, recoveries, turnovers on downs and missed/blocked kicks. Position is where the next offense takes over.

D/ST TD +6 with no extra possession award; safety +2 plus eligible possession award; offensive TD allowed −1; FG allowed −0.5; special-teams TD allowed −1. No separate sack, interception, forced-fumble or recovery bonus. Final per-game floor: −4.

Ordinary kickoffs and period-ending possessions do not earn an award. A same-play turnover returned to the original offense earns no possession award. A defensive TD by the opponent does not penalize the offense’s D/ST.

Report reconciliations

The live calculation held three flags. Play-by-play review resolved them as follows. CIN and CHI were not rostered, so these adjustments affect only the all-defense comparison. This file does not change the live scorer or any Sleeper scores.

D/STLive calculationReportEvidence
CIN3.59.5Q1 6:18: Demetrius Knight Jr. returned a fumble 27 yards for a touchdown. ESPN labels the play “Sack Opp Fumble Recovery”; its touchdown and CIN scoring-team fields confirm the +6 omitted by the live parser. Play-by-play ↗
CHI5.57.0Q4 15:00: Tetairoa McMillan fumbled and Devin Bush recovered. The next Chicago snap at Q4 14:50 began at CHI 39, confirming a +1.5 possession award. Repeated wording for the same fumble caused the live parser to hold this event. Play-by-play ↗
TB3.53.5The Cincinnati defensive touchdown does not count as an offensive touchdown allowed by Tampa Bay. Resolving its classification clears the warning without changing TB’s score. Play-by-play ↗

Snapshot and source data

Sleeper data retrieved September 15, 2026 at 12:47 p.m. ET; custom dashboard source data as of 12:40 p.m. ET. All games were complete. Scores remain subject to corrections; the dashboard’s configured correction window ends September 16 at 12:00 a.m. ET. This HTML contains a fixed snapshot and does not refresh automatically.

Default preset version: sleeper-default-2026-09-09.1. Custom scorer version: 2026-09-09.5, plus the report reconciliations above. Component data and source identifiers are embedded in this file for reproducibility.